Incorporated village

Muttontown property taxes

What goes into a Muttontown property tax bill, and how to grieve your assessment.

See if you’re over-assessed →
GreenvaleEast NorwichOyster BayGlen HeadJerichoWoodburyPlainviewHicksvilleMatinecockLaurel HollowBrookvilleOld BrookvilleOld WestburyMuttontown
Town of Oyster Bay · Nassau County

Muttontown grievance scorecard

11.1%
typical grievance cut, Oyster Bay-East Norwich schools
66%
of homes in the district filed
4
school districts serve Muttontown

Among homeowners in the Oyster Bay-East Norwich school district who won a grievance, the typical cut to the assessed value was 11.1%. Some homes get more, some less, and some get nothing. Parts of Muttontown are in the Syosset (8%) and Jericho (10%) and Locust Valley (7.9%) districts instead. From Nassau’s last two published assessment rolls.

What’s on a Muttontown tax bill

  • School taxesUsually the largest part of the bill, set by your school district’s budget.
  • Nassau County taxesCounty government, including the county police for most of Nassau.
  • Town taxesThe Town of Oyster Bay general fund and town services.
  • Village taxes (separate bill)Billed separately by the Village of Muttontown.

Does a Nassau grievance lower village taxes?

Usually not. A Nassau County grievance lowers the assessed value behind your school, county and town taxes, which are most of the bill. The village tax is the Village of Muttontown’s own. Many Nassau villages assess it on their own roll, with their own grievance day, forms and deadline, and a Nassau grievance doesn’t reach it. Ask the village clerk how the village assesses and when its grievance day is.

How to grieve

Nassau County’s filing window for the 2028/29 tax year runs from January 4, 2027 to March 1, 2027. Filing can’t raise your assessment. You can file yourself with the Assessment Review Commission, hire a firm that keeps a share of your savings, or use our app: see your comparable sales first, then file for $99 flat. Read the full guide.

Nassau homeowners love how easy it is

Michele B.
★★★★★

This site was a home run! It was easy to navigate and I was able to get my assessment down over 10%. If I had one of the tax grievance companies do it for me I wouldn’t have saved nearly as much $. I highly recommend doing the process on your own through Nassau Tax Buddy.

Google review
Bruce M.
★★★★★

Easy to use! Efficient and takes the guess work out of a sometimes confusing process! I recommend it and will use it again next year!

Google review
Neil T.
★★★★★

This was awesome. I thought doing a reassessment was going to be a pain, which is why I never did it. Using this made it so easy and explained everything. Within 15 minutes I was done!

Google review

Ready to lower your property taxes?

Type your address to see your assessed value, recent sales near you and what you could save.

See your estimate for free.

$99 flat to file. Not a percentage of your savings.