What SCAR is
Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) is a low-cost review run by the New York State courts. A hearing officer looks at your evidence and Nassau’s and decides whether your assessment should be lower. It is meant for homeowners and doesn’t require a lawyer.
New York requires you to go through the administrative review first. In Nassau, that means grieving with ARC before you can file for SCAR.
When to file
SCAR comes after ARC publishes its final determination, which happens in April after the year you filed. The filing window after that is short, so check the exact deadline on the New York State courts’ SCAR page as soon as your determination arrives.
What it costs
The court filing fee is $30, paid when you file. You present your own case, usually with the same comparable sales you used for your grievance. Most owners of homes they live in can use SCAR; the courts’ site lists who qualifies.
Because the bar for a different result is a hearing officer seeing your value differently from ARC, the strength of your comparable sales matters even more here.
If you filed with us
SCAR isn’t part of the $99. If Nassau doesn’t lower your assessed value, our reduction guarantee refunds your fee. If you decide to go to SCAR anyway, we’ll send you the comparable sales we filed and walk you through the form.