The 6% cap catching up
For homes (Class 1), Nassau’s assessment can’t rise more than 6% over the prior year or more than 20% within five years. When home prices rise faster than that, your assessment climbs by up to the cap each year until it catches up to where Nassau thinks your market value is.
So a 6% increase doesn’t necessarily mean your home was singled out. It often means the cap is doing its job, one step at a time.
A reduction you won last time
A reduction doesn’t automatically carry into the next year. The Department of Assessment reviews values every year, so a value you won can rise again on the next tentative roll. The reduced value does become the starting point for the 6% limit, which is why a homeowner who won last year often sees roughly a 6% rise the next.
That is the main reason to file every year.
Renovations and new construction
Value added by new construction or a renovation is not limited by the cap. An addition, a finished basement or a new bathroom can raise your assessment by more than 6% in one year.
If your record shows work you didn’t do, or square footage that’s wrong, that is worth raising in a grievance.
What to do about it
The question that matters is whether your new value is higher than comparable homes support. If recent sales of similar homes near you came in below the market value Nassau implies for yours, you have a case. The filing window for the 2028/29 tax year runs from January 4, 2027 to March 1, 2027.