The short answer
Nassau County’s own guidance answers this directly: an appeal to the Assessment Review Commission will either reduce your assessment or leave it unchanged. Filing does not put your home at risk of a higher value.
That is the main reason grieving is close to risk-free. The worst outcome of an ordinary grievance is that nothing changes.
What can still change your value
Your assessment can still change for reasons that have nothing to do with filing. Nassau publishes a new tentative assessment every January, and value added by new construction or a renovation is assessed regardless of whether you grieve. The Department of Assessment can also correct clerical errors on a property record.
None of those are triggered by a grievance, and all of them would happen whether or not you filed.
Why people worry about it
The worry usually comes from the idea that drawing attention to a house invites a closer look. In Nassau, ARC’s job is to decide whether to lower the value you challenged. Across the last published cycle, about 9 in 10 homeowners who filed got some reduction, while almost no one who didn’t file saw their assessment go down.