You inherited the previous owner’s assessment
Nassau doesn’t reassess a house because it sold. The assessed value on your first tax bill is the one the county already had on the books, which may have been set years ago and may never have been challenged. Whether it was right for the seller tells you nothing about whether it’s right for you.
When your purchase price helps
Nassau’s market value for your home is your assessed value divided by the county’s level of assessment. If you paid less than that figure in a normal sale, you have direct evidence the county values your home too high.
It counts most when the sale was:
- Recent, ideally within the last two years.
- Arm’s length: listed on the open market, between strangers. A sale between relatives, a foreclosure auction or a quitclaim transfer doesn’t show what the house is worth.
If you paid more than Nassau’s figure, you can still have a case. Recent sales of similar homes nearby decide it, and those can come in lower than what you paid.
Two things to check first
- Did the seller already file for this year? If the previous owner signed with a grievance firm, a second filing on the same house for the same tax year can get both rejected. Ask the seller or your attorney before you file.
- Is your STAR credit set up? New owners don’t inherit the seller’s STAR. You register with New York State yourself. How STAR works.
When to file
The window for the 2028/29 tax year runs from January 4, 2027 to March 1, 2027. If you own the home when you file, you can file. A reduction shows up on bills starting in October 2028.